نوع مقاله : مقاله پژوهشی
نویسنده
Tsuda University
10.48308/piaj.2026.247371.2025
چکیده
Introduction
Nearly a century after Arthur Ponsonby catalogued recurring patterns of wartime deception, and more than twenty-five years after Anne Morelli distilled them into ten principles, the conditions under which war propaganda is produced and received have changed substantially. Digital platforms have accelerated the circulation of wartime accounts and altered how they gain visibility and credibility, yet many of the rhetorical devices identified by Ponsonby and Morelli remain recognisable. This article revisits their work to distinguish enduring mechanisms from changes in how they operate. It argues that war propaganda cannot be understood solely as the dissemination of falsehoods. It can also work through the selection of accurate but incomplete information, the unequal treatment of sources, and the application of different moral standards to allies and adversaries.
Method
The article develops a revised framework through a conceptual comparison of Ponsonby’s observations, Morelli’s principles, and subsequent scholarship on persuasion, framing, agenda-setting, institutional power, and computational propaganda. This selective review informs decisions about which principles to retain, combine, or reformulate and where additional maxims are needed. The analysis draws on Entman’s account of framing to examine what public statements and media reports foreground or omit, whose claims they treat as credible, and how they assign responsibility. Examples from recent conflicts, drawn from public statements, media reporting, and published research, illustrate how the maxims can be applied. They are not used to estimate the prevalence of particular practices or measure their effects on audiences.
Findings
The resulting framework comprises fifteen maxims. A recurring pattern is that the same kinds of claims or actions are assessed differently depending on who makes or undertakes them. One’s own side is presented as seeking peace and defending a legitimate order, while adversaries are portrayed as inherently threatening and their states are reduced to the character and intentions of their leaders. The use of force by one’s own side may be judged by its stated intentions, while an adversary’s actions are judged by their consequences. Similar asymmetries shape how military losses and civilian deaths are reported, how comparable intelligence practices are labelled, and whose claims are accepted without independent corroboration. The framework also examines how fear can be mobilised, how restrictions on information can be justified as protection against disinformation, and how repetition and omission can make partial accounts appear complete. Algorithmic amplification and coordinated online activity can increase the visibility of preferred accounts or create an impression of consensus. Generative artificial intelligence adds new ways to produce persuasive material and complicates assessments of authenticity.
Conclusion
The fifteen maxims extend the earlier frameworks by bringing rhetorical practices, institutional sources of credibility, and digital amplification into the same analysis. They offer a way to examine how particular interpretations of war become accepted as facts while competing accounts receive less attention or are dismissed. Identifying a maxim does not establish that a claim is false, that its presentation reflects a coordinated campaign, or that the conduct of opposing parties is equivalent. Those judgements require independent verification and attention to context. The framework is intended to guide that inquiry rather than substitute for it.
کلیدواژهها