Achievements and Requirements of Teachers' Guild-Political Activism (2010s)

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

1 Assistant Professor, Political Sociology, Faculty of Law and Political Science, Shiraz University, Shiraz, Iran

2 PhD Candidate, Political Science, Faculty of Law and Political Science, Shiraz University, Shiraz, Iran

Abstract

 
Extended abstract
Introduction and Purpose: The teachers' guild-political activism in the 2010s is not only considered as a new phase in the history of their guild-political activism, it has also various aspects and traits such as non-violence, high participation, inclusiveness and continuity which significantly distinguished it from their past activism and even that of other social groups. The main purpose of this research is to assess the achievements of teachers' guild-political activism in the 2010s and the requirements of their activism. Although their requirements and their achievements are different aspects of their guild-political activism, these aspects are correlated: the former (requirements) advances the latter (achievements).
 Method:  Since this research deals with two separate but interrelated questions (i.e. it assumes that the requirements are the foundation of achievements) and it also assesses the achievements through quantitative method and the requirements through qualitative method, thereby, the data analysis method is a mixed method: multi-level mixed method. The achievement data was collected through semi-open interviews (8 closed questions and 8 open questions) with 30 teachers' guild-political activists, and then the average of all interviewees' responses (based on the Likert scale) in each item has been analyzed. The requirement data has also been collected through library and qualitative method, and finally, by placing all the data together, a final analysis has been concluded.
Findings: The findings of the research indicate that among the eight significant professional-political achievements of teachers (both in-guild and out-guild), the most important achievements, in order, are the approval of the teacher ranking plan, the strengthening of solidarity and cohesion, the importance of the existence of the profession and its associated structures, and setting an example for other organizations. Their most important requirements have been, also, strategic unity, promotion of the civil-legal trainings of their activism, the continuity of their guild membership process, making the educational system accountable and education policies more efficient. Among 8 items of their guild-political achievements, the approval of rating plan with 4.16% is the highest average and the improvement of living conditions is the lowest average with 1.3%. In total, the guild achievements with 70.3% frequency are more important than non-guild achievements with 3.47%. The requirements of teachers' activism, which advance their achievements are as follow: following one strategic unity, promotion of the civil-legal trainings of their activism, the continuity of their guild membership process, making the educational system accountable and education policies more efficient (meritocracy, decreasing the leadership level of government, improving the social dignity of teachers through governance discourse, paying attention to their livelihood policies, paying attention to educational demands, redefining the professional identity of teachers) and recognizing their guild.
Conclusion: The achievements or successes of teachers' activism, both in the past and in the future, are dependent on requirements such as making educational policies more efficient through the promotion of some parameters such as meritocracy, decreasing the leadership level of government, improving the social dignity of teachers, paying attention to their livelihood policies, paying attention to educational demands etc., on one hand, and recognizing their associations by political system. Although this research has some deficiencies, it can be a step for future researches regarding other dimensions of teachers' activism, educational issues, socio-cultural development issues and the future researches of various social movements and other guild movements; thereby, this research can lead to a favorable scientific and practical result for better policies through a thematic and methodical survey.
 

Keywords


‒ Adibi, Hosein (1979), New Middle Class in Iran, 1th publication, Tehran: Jameae Pub (In Persian).
‒ Anthony Giddens (2005), World Perspectives, translated by Mohammadreza Jalayipour, 2th published, Tehran: Tarhe No Pub (In Persian).
‒ Apple, Michael (2019a), Can Education Change Society? translated by Nazanin Mirzabeigi, Tehran: Agah pub. (In Persian).
‒ Apple, Michael (2000), Official Knowledge, 2nd Edition, London: Routledge.
‒ Apple, Michael (2019b), official knowledge: Democratic Education in a Conservative Age, translated by Nazanin Mirzabeigi, Tehran: Agah pub. (In Persian).
‒ Baizidi, Rahim (2019), "Paradoxical Class: Paradox of Interest in Middle Class and Political Conservatism", Asian Journal of Political Science, Volume 27, Issue 3.
‒ Day, C. (2002), Developing teachers: The challenges of lifelong learning, London: Routledge. ‒ Ebrahimi Doushtoor E, Mahdiuon R, Rafiee M, Razzaghi M, (2021), "Lived Experience of Teachers' union Members' Activities and Problems of Teachers' union: (Case Study: Members of East Azerbaijan Teachers' union:)", Journal of Managing Education in Organizations, 11th year, No: 2 (In Persian), Doi: 10.52547/MEO.10.2.51
‒ Freire, Paulo (2019), Education for Critical Consciousness, translated by Mansooreh Kaviyani, 2th published, Tehran, Agah Pub (In Persian).
‒ Giroux, H. (1994), "Teachers, Public Life, and Curriculum Reform", Peabody Journal of Education, 69(3): 35-47, DOI:10.1080/01619569409538776
‒ Giroux, H. (2005), Border Crossing: Cultural and the Politics of Education, Second Edition, New York: Routledge. ‒ Giroux, H. (2009), Youth in a Suspect Society, Macmillan: Palgrave Press.
‒ Hezarjoraibi Jafar (2010), "Theoretical Investigation The Recognition of The Middle Class (Emphasis On New Middle Class In Iran)", Social Science Quarterly, 17th Year, No: 50, (In Persian) Doi: 10.22054/qjss.2010.6812
‒ Kalb, Zep (2017), "Another Brick in Wall, Protesting Education in Iran" (https://merip.org/2017/11/another-brick-in-the-wall/)
‒ Law on Political groups and parties activitism (2016), Research Center of Islamic Parlement (https://rc.majlis.ir/fa/law/show/998916) (In Persian).
‒ Martyn, Denscombe (2019), The Good Research Guide: For Small-scale Social research, translated by Sajjad Alizadeh & Sajjad Yahak, Tehran, Scientific and Cultural Pub (In Persian).
‒ Max, Weber (2009), Economy and Society, translated by Abbas Mokhber, Mehrdad Torabi Nezhad & Mostafa Emadzadeh, 6th published, Tehran: Samt Pub (In Persian).
‒ McCollow, J. (2018), "The Future of Education Unions", Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Education, (https://www.researchgate.net/publication/327164569_The_Future_of_Education_Unions)
‒ Mohammadzadeh, Hosein & Nasrollah Nadimi (2022), "the relation between type of ethnic identities and political behavior and individual values among high school teacher (Case study: Kamyaran high school teachers)", Sociological Cultural Studies, 16th Year, No: 1 (In Persian), Doi: 10.30465/SCS.2022.38781.2480
‒ Mohammadi, Hamdollah & Najmeh AhmadAbadi Arani (2017), "A critical review of the ideas of Richard Rorty and Henry Giroux on the Intellectual Education", Journal of Philosophy & History of Education, No: 1 (In Persian).
‒ Moosavi, Mohammad (2021), Sociological Study on Restriction and Teachers' Association Potentialities in Tehran Province (2006-2021), Master Thesis, Tarbiat Modarres University, Humanity Faculty (In Persian).
‒ Neametollah, Fazeli (2022), School Problem; Critical reflection on Iran Education, Tehran, Hooshe Nab Pub (In Persian).
‒ Salari, Masaood (2019), Restriction on Guil Associations with Emphasis on Teachers' Guil Rights, Master Thesis, Bandarabas Azad University, Humanity Faculty (In Persian).
‒ Niknejad, Mohammadreza (2019), "Why Iranian Teachers Are Protesting", ALMONITOR,) https://www.al-monitor.com/originals/2019/01/iran-teachers-protest-strike-siting-working-conditions.html)
‒ Shahramnia, Seyed Amirmasoud & Saber Mollaiy (2010), "Analysis of the Impact of Teachers’ Political Awareness on Participation in Elections", Ipsajournal, 6th Year, No: 1 (In Persian).
‒ Sharepoor, Mahmood (2003), Education Sociology, Tehran: Samt Pub (In Persian).
‒ Statistic Anniversary of Baeurocratic System in 1401 (2022), Public Administration and Recruitment Organization, Office of Data-base Governance Development (https://www.aro.gov.ir/_douranportal/documents/201401) (In Persian).
‒ Weis, Cameron McCarthy & Greg Dimitriadis (2018), Ideology, Curriculum, and the New Sociology of Education, translated by Nazanin Mirzabeigi, Tehran: Agah Pub (In Persian).
‒ Zeinab, Khosroo & Zahra Rezaeinasab (2014), "Comparative survey of Karl Marx and Max Weber's Theories and Votes in the Field of Social inequality", Economic Quarterly, Vol 14, No: 7 & 8 (In Persian).
‒ Zibakalam Mofrad, Fatemeh & Hamdollah Mohammadi (2014), "A Comparative Study of Critical Thinking from the Viewpoint of Robert Ennis and Henry Giroux Considering Its Application for the Modification of Teacher Training System", Journal of Applied Psycology Research, 5th year, Vol 3 (In Persian), Doi: 10.22059/JAPR.2014.52282