political thought of Sayyed Ahmad Barilavi

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

1 Professor of Political Science, Department of Political Science, Faculty of Law and Political Science, Al-Mustafa Al-Alamiya Community, Qom, Iran.

2 Associate Professor of Political Science, Faculty of Social Sciences. Research Institute and University, Qom, Iran.

3 PhD, Department of Political Science, Faculty of Law and Political Science, Al-Mustafa Al-Alamiya University, Qom, Iran.

Abstract

Introduction: Seyyed Ahmad Barelvi is one of the few revolutionary Sufis of the Indian subcontinent who transformed his political thought from theory to practice through jihad and armed uprising. Barelvi's political thought was not unrelated to the crises and disorders of his time. The central issue of this article is the relationship between Sayyid Ahmad Barelvi's political thought and the crises and disorders of his era. The core question of this inquiry is: according to Sayyid Ahmad Barelvi, what were the crises facing the society of the Indian subcontinent at that time, what did he consider their roots and causes, and what was his ideal political order and the solutions he prescribed for overcoming these crises?
Methods: This article employs Thomas Spragens' "crisis theory" model as the theoretical framework and research methodology to explain Sayyid Ahmad Barelvi's political thought. Spragens developed his method to uncover and understand the "inner logic" of political theory. According to him, every political theory emerges from the crisis of its time, considering the current state (what is) and the desired state (what ought to be). Spriggans believes that the great art of a political theory is to provide a way to integrate the "what is" with the "what ought to be."
Findings: Sayyid Ahmad perceived the political powers of his time as being in conflict with his theoretical foundations and value system as a Muslim. Additionally, the contemporary political systems were acquiring power illegitimately, and the Islamic political order was gradually losing its ability to sustain itself. Therefore, by contemplating concepts such as Imamate, Jihad, and governance, he sought to pave the way for a transformation in the political order and a legitimate transfer of power. This set of efforts came to be known as "Tariqat-i-Muhammadiya" (the Mohammadian Way). Ultimately, although "Tariqat-i-Muhammadiya" failed to establish a new order and implement a legitimate governance based on its politico-religious principles, it was somewhat successful in delegitimizing and discrediting the "right to rule" of colonial and despotic powers. Barelvi was ultimately defeated due to the greed and betrayal of certain Pashtun leaders who disregarded his directives for a principled jihad. Barelvi's concept of jihad entailed a specific understanding of warfare that was incompatible with material goals aimed at collecting spoils. These principles effectively imposed constraints on his fighters, who were primarily from the Pashtun tribes. The Pashtun leaders rejected these constraints, abandoned Barelvi's principles of jihad, and instead focused on accumulating war spoils. The Pashtuns' strong desire for booty created the first rift in Sayyid Ahmad's movement. Subsequently, this rift expanded to other issues, such as the incompatibility between Sayyid Ahmad's orthodox principles and the tribal traditions of the Pashtuns, leading to the failure of Barelvi's movement. Despite this, the ‘Tariqat-i Muhammadiyya’ movement had a significant religious impact on contemporary Islamic movements and notably influenced the Taliban in Afghanistan both militarily and politically.
Conclusion: According to Barelvi, the main crises are categorized as "political" and "religious." He considers the root of these crises to be "shirk" (polytheism) and "kufr" (disbelief). Barelvi's ideal political order involves eradicating polytheism and disbelief, elevating the word of God, reviving the Quran and the traditions of the Prophet Muhammad, and establishing a native Islamic state. His practical solution to resolve these crises and transition from the current state to the desired state involves the continuous implementation of "military jihad." However, ultimately, Sayyid Ahmad Barelvi fails in the execution of his strategies.

Keywords

References

‒ Ahmad, Aziz (1366), History of Islamic Thought in India, first edition,translated by Naghi Lotfi and Mohammad Jafar Yahaghi, first edition, Tehran: Kayhan Publications.[in Persian]
‒ Akwani, Hamdallah and others(1401), "Taliban's intellectual foundations based on Spriggans' research method; From collapse to regaining strength". Bi-quarterly Scientific Journal of Political Sociology of the Islamic World, Volume 10, Number 2, Autumn and Winter. pp. 257-282.[in Persian]
‒ Al-Fawz al-Kabeer fi Usul al-Tafseer, first edition, translated from Persian to Arabic by Salman Al-Husseini al-Nadawi, Zahedan: Siddiqi Publications. [in Arabic]
‒ Al-Hassan, Moshir (1367), Islamic Movement and Ethnic Tendencies in Indian Colony, Mashhad:Astan Quds Razavi Islamic Research Foundation.[in Persian]
‒ Ali Babaei, Gholamreza (2012), Arash Political Culture, first edition, Tehran: Ashian. [in Persian]
‒ Allahar, Anton L. (1993), "When Black First Became Worth Less." International Journal of Comparative Sociology, 14:427-444.
‒ Bahadur, Nawab Mohammad Wazir Khan (1328 AH), The events of Seyyed Ahmad Shaheed, first edition, by Seyyed Nafis Al-Husseini, Lahore: Seyed Ahmad Shaheed Academy.[in Urdu]
‒ Barfield, Thomas (2010), Afghanistan: A Cultural and Political History, Princeton University Press.
‒ Barfield, Thomas (2010), Afghanistan:A Cultural and Political History, Princeton University Press.
‒ Barilavi, Seyed Ahmad Shahid (1975), Schools of Syed Ahmad Shaheed, first edition, Lahore:Rashidiya School. Dehlavi, Shah Abdul Aziz(1322 AH).[in Persian]
‒ Carey, Simon (2012), “The Legacy of British Colonialism in India Post 1947,” New Zealand Review of Economics and Finance. Vol 2.
‒ Carey, Simon (2012), “The Legacy of British Colonialism in India Post 1947,” New Zealand Review of Economics and Finance. Vol 2. (https://doi.org/10.26686/nzref.v2i0.1740)
‒ Dehlavi, Abdul Haq(1867), Punishment of the heedless of the world and the masters; In (Kitab al-Makatib wa al-Rashee al-Arbab al-Kamal wa al-Fadhail), corrected by Muhammad Anwar al-Haq Haqi al-Qadri Dehlavi, Delhi: Manuscript.[in Persian]
‒ Dehlavi, Shah Waliullah (2005 AD/ 1426 AH), Hojjatullah al-Balagha, recording and notes of Mohammad Salem Hashem, second edition, Beirut: Dar al-Kitab al-Alamiya. Dehlavi, Shah Valiullah (1382).[in Arabic] ‒
Fatawi Azizi,revised by Muhammad Abdul Ahad, Delhi: Mujtabai Publisher.[in Persian]
‒ Hanafi,Abdul Salam (1376), "Speech at the meeting of the Supreme Council of the Taliban"; Published in: Tolo Afghan magazine (Taliban publication in Pashto language, number 56, 23/9/1376.[in Pashto]
‒ Haqqani, Hosain (2005), “The Ideologies of South Asian Jihadi Groups”, https://carnegieendowment.org/files/ideologies.pdf. ‒ Hasan, Tariq (2015), Colonialism and the Call to Jihad in British India, New Delhi: SAGE Publications India Pvt Ltd.
‒ Hosni, Abdul Hai bin Fakhreddin (1399 AH/ 1979 AD), Nozeha Al-Khwatar and Baheja Al-Masami wa Al-Nawazir, second edition, Hyderabad, Deccan: Al-Othmaniyah Encyclopedia. [in Arabic]
‒ Hosni, Mohammad Hamzeh (1996), Hazrat Syed Ahmad Shahid's Tadzkire, Karachi: Shakil Printang Paris. [in Urdu]
‒ Hunter, W. W.(1945), The Indian Musalmans, Third Editon. Calcutta: The Comrade Publishers.
‒ Hunter,W.W.(1945), The Indian Musalmans,Third Editon.Calcutta:The Comrade Publishers.
‒ Ibn Abd al-Wahhab, Muhammad (1429/2008), Kitab al-Tawheed, expulsion and suspension of Abu Malik al-Riyasi, first edition, Cairo: Ebad al-Rahman School.[in Arabic]
‒ Jalal, Ayesha (2008), Partisans of Allah: Jihad in South Asia, Harvard University Press. ‒ Jalal,Ayesha (2008), Partisans of Allah: Jihad in South Asia, Harvard University Press.
‒ Khan, Abdullah (1984), The Religious Thought of Shah Ismail Dihlawi, (A Thesis Submitted to the Faculty of Graduate Studies and Research, Institute of Islamic Studies, March 1984.) Montreal: McGill University.
‒ Khan, Abdullah (1984), The Religious Thought of Shah Ismail Dihlawi, (A Thesis Submitted to the Faculty of Graduate Studies and Research, Institute of Islamic Studies, March 1984.) Montreal: McGill University.
‒ Mallick, Azizur Rahman (1977), British Policy and the Muslims in Bengal, Second Edition, Dacca: Bangla Academy.
‒ Mallick, Azizur Rahman (1977), British Policy and the Muslims in Bengal, Second Edition, Dacca: Bangla Academy.
‒ Mehr, Gholam Rasul (2008), Tehreek Seyyed Ahmad Shaheed, known as "Story of Mujahideen", Bibai: Maktaba Al-Haq.[in Urdu]
‒ Metcalf, Barbara , d. (1388), "Syed Ahmad Barilvi"; In the encyclopedia of the modern world of Islam, under the supervision of John. L. Esposito, first edition, translation and research under the supervision of Hasan Tarimi Rad and others, Tehran: Ketab Marjah Publishing.[in Persian]
‒ Moliner, Christine (2007) Frères ennemis? Relations between Panjabi Sikhs and Muslims in the Diaspora. (https://doi.org/10.4000/samaj.135)
‒ Moliner, Christine (2007), Frères ennemis? Relations between Panjabi Sikhs and Muslims in the Diaspora. ‒ Nizami, Taufiq Ahmad (1965), Muslem Political Thouth and Attitude in Northern India During the first half of the 19th century, Aligarh Muslim University.
‒ Nizami,K.Ay and Aziz Ahmad(2012), "Examination of the evolution of Islamic religious thought in the subcontinent from the 6th to the 13th century BC", translated by Ahmad Reza Ebadi, Haft Asman publication, year 15, number 59.[in Persian]
‒ Nizami,Taufiq Ahmad (1965), Muslem Political Thouth and Attitude in Northern India During the first half of the 19th century, Aligarh Muslim University.
‒Roa,Aliwieh (1369), Afghanistan, Islam and political modernity,translated by Abul Hassan Sarmoghadam, first edition, Mashhad: Astan Quds Razavi Cultural Vice-Chancellor.[in Persian]
‒ Saeed Khan, Mohammad (1981 AD), Life stories of Seyed Ahmed Shahid, first edition, Rawalpindi: Yes Printers Press. [in Urdu]
‒ Salek, Shamsullah (1439), "The public mentality of enlightening the spirit of Jihad al-Dalai", https://www.mujali.af/?p=1149[in Pashto]
‒ Sandhu, Harmeet S. (2014) "British Raj: The Legacy of Colonialism in India,"Sociological Imagination: Western’s UndergraduateSociology Student Journal: Vol. 3: Iss. 1. (https://ojs.lib.uwo.ca/index.php/si/article/view/5280/4425)
‒ Sandhu,Harmeet S.(2014), "British Raj: The Legacy of Colonialism in India,"Sociological Imagination: Western’s UndergraduateSociology Student Journal:Vol.3:Iss.1.
‒ Sandi, Obeidullah (1396/1976), Al-Tamahid for the definition of imams of Tajid, first edition, research and suspension of Ghulam Mustafa Al-Qasami Al-Sandi, Hyderabad (Pakistan):Jamia Al-Sand Press.[in Arabic]
‒ Seyyed Abulhasan Ali (2010), When Nasim Iman Wazeed (the biography of Mujahid Kabir Seyyed Ahmad Shahid),translated by Mohammad Ebrahim Damani, first edition,Zahedan: Sedighi Publications. [in Persian]
‒ Seyyed Mohammad Ismail(1246), Sarat Tessim, Lahore:Al-Maktaba al-Salfiyyah. Nadvi,[in Persian]
‒ Spriggans, Thomas (1370), Understanding political theories, translated by Farhang Rajaei, first edition, Tehran: Ageh.[in Persian]
‒ Woll, John O (2008), "The ways of Sufi"; in the encyclopedia of the modern world of Islam, under the supervision of John L. Esposito, first edition, translation and research under the supervision of Hassan Tarimi Rad and others, Tehran: Reference book publication. [in Persian]

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics